10 Leading Mattresses – Understanding Your Baby’s Sleep

Are you expecting your first little bundle of joy? Maybe even two?My First Premium Memory Foam Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress

If you are like most nervous new parents, you probably are wondering about the best products for your baby, including the best crib mattress.

If this sounds like you, don’t worry.

We have identified ten of the best mattresses you can buy and we are giving you all that you need to choose your favorite. Read on and discover for yourself. Don’t be surprised if you find the perfect mattress to last between now and when you buy your first set of bunk beds for your little treasure’s room.

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Mattress

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Mattress

Safety 1st is a company that has made it a mission to provide safe baby products. The Heavenly Dreams crib and toddler bed mattress is no exception. The mattress comes in many different themed covers like “Stars a Plenty,” which is covered in an intricate star pattern. The thermo-bonded fiber core offers strong yet supple support for preemies through preschoolers.

It is also durable and lightweight. The durable, waterproof cover is easy to clean after an accident and is durable enough to resist a curious toddler or withstand a vigorous scrub. The mattress has earned a GREENGUARD GOLD certification, which meant that it meets the certified standards for low chemical emissions.

The mattress also meets federal flammability standard 16 CFR 1633. This means it can protect your baby without the use of potentially harmful fire retardant chemicals. Safe? Check. Cute? Check. Easy to Clean? Double check. This mattress is a winner in just about every way.

  • Product
  • Photos

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Stars a Plenty Baby Mattress, Light Pink

Settle baby down on the Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Stars a Plenty crib and toddler bed mattress, covered in an intricate star pattern for a good night’s sleep. The thermo-bonded fiber core offers ...

Available: In stock
Buy this item
amazon amazon.com
Bought this mattress in March 2016 and by November noticed it was tearing and coming apart. As far as I can tell the bits and pieces stayed beneath the crib sheet. Very worried my LO may have swallowed some pieces.Tried to contact the manufacturer, but can't find a phone number.
December 10, 2016
Shocked that this got such great reviews. Advertised as 52.5 inches in length, it is 49 inches and does NOT fit our standard size crib. It is too short of either side. I could almost fit his entire hand between the mattress and the end of the crib. Incredibly disappointed.
June 5, 2015
FINAL UPDATE: 3/21/2015Hey everybody! I just wanted to provide another (and likely the last) update to the ongoing mattress review. We upgraded to a big girl bed months ago, however, the mattress was still in great shape, so I donated it to a friends who were expecting a "surprise" baby. Well, said baby caught a viral bug and got sick in the crib. Today, I got a call from the mom RAVING about how resilient the mattress was. She cleaned with clorox spray and that was it. No stains, no odor, no nothing. I still love this mattress and think it will be one of your wises baby investments. I want to thank everyone for all of the comments, funny emails and questions! I welcome anymore anytime. Good luck with the kids! Six year olds are totally cray-cray, BTW ;)UPDATE: 2/3/2014Hi everyone! We just converted the crib to a toddler bed last week for a very sneaky and clever 27 month old. We still use this same mattress and we still adore it. Sheets are the same, blankets are the same, only now she can come and go out of bed as she pleases. No worries...her room has been "sweeped" for dangers and there is an additional baby gate at the door to keep Houdini safely inside. If anyone wants to check out my blog, it's loaded with this kind of thing plus a ton of other helpful (and humorous!) stories, how tos, reviews and how not tos! If you like it, please share with your friends as well as your internet friends...Thanks so much!! [...]UPDATE: 5/30/13This mattress is still AHHH-MAZING!! I say this because it has retained it's shape and form beautifully and if baby's diaper leaks overnight (and they will as they get bigger!) you can easily clean the mess. We use a waterproof mattress pad, but still, when everything is in the wash, I still give it a good wipe down. Baby loves it and she's 20 months now. One thing i really appreciate about it and you may not care about this, but since there are no springs, she has never had the urge to try and jump up and down on it and escape the crib.Also, some of you have asked about the size of the mattress and it is at least average crib mattress size, if not longer. I am paranoid by design and I never had one unsafe thought or experience with this mattress. I suppose if you are using an older crib or a HUGE one, you may have minor issues, but we use a solid wood crib to full size bed convertible type ($$!...don't even get me started on the cost of a good heirloom crib!), and nada...no problems.Feel free to contact me here with any questions. I was happy to see that so many people enjoyed my original review and I am more than happy to answer any questions- big or small- that you may have. I love this mattress more now then I did nearly two years ago and I am super finicky. For the price, you simply can't lose.________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________I ordered this mattress 2 days ago and it was on my doorstep this afternoon. I have to say that I am floored by the quality. This is for our second daughter (on her way) and our oldest used a mattress 2x this price and when I compared them side by side, I was blown away.Here's why:1. It's a dense, high quality memory foam with a waterproof cover on it (removable)2. Contrary to what other reviewers say, it's big; as a matter of fact, it's a good 1.5" longer than our brand name more expensive mattress that pales in comparison. The old one is like sitting on a series of crunchy springs and the new one is like sitting on a tempur-pedic with a non-crunchy waterproof cover.I did a lot of anal retentive research in this purchase and am shocked that this is the real price for this mattress. Don't hesitate on this one. It feels and looks very high end. You'll be glad I did all the psychotic research for you in advance.
July 22, 2011


  • Thermo-bonded core
  • Mattress cover features an intricate star pattern
  • Durable vinyl cover is waterproof


Heavenly Dreams crib and toddler bed mattress covers all of the basics. It works well, lasts a long time, is environmentally, and is reasonably priced. It is also easy to find. You can find this and other Safety 1st products at most major retailers as well as online.

Sound perfect?

Great. But just wait, we have nine other mattresses that may be just as perfect for your little bundle.

  • Free of fire-retardant chemicals and vapors
  • Waterproof and easy to clean
  • Lightweight
  • Comes in a series of cute themed prints
  • Safety 1st Items are available at many stores like Walmart and Babies R Us
  • High-density foam doesn’t flatten over time and use, which makes it long-lasting.
  • Free of phthalates and lead
  • Reviews say that this mattress can work well through several kids
  • Relatively low price for this quality of mattress

  • Some gapping when used in a standard-sized crib
  • If outer coating is breached, children can shred the foam core

back to menu ↑

Sealy Soybean Foam Core Mattress

Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Infant/Toddler Crib MattressForget plastic! If you really want to go green, then this Sealy Soybean Foam Core Mattress might be just the mattress for you. The foam core of this mattress is made not from fossil fuels but good old fashioned soybeans. This means that after its long, durable life, it is biodegradable in a landfill.

Its lightweight, pearl-embossed waterproof cover is easy to clean. Square corners mean no digging under the mattress for a stray pacifier. Lock-stitching on the edges helps the durability of this mattress. It measures 52 by 58 by 5 inches and fits newborns to 60 lbs.

This award-winner has multiple accolades as most recommended by baby through the Women’s Choice Awards. How about that!

  • Product
  • Photos

Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress - Hypoallergenic Soy Foam, Extra Firm,...

Parent-tested and approved, the highly-rated Sealy Soybean Foam-Core crib mattress is the original mattress that used renewable soybeans to help create a firm foam for infants and toddlers

Available: In stock
Buy this item
amazon amazon.com
We've been using this for nearly 2 years with a Walmart Baby Mod Olivia crib, and we've been really happy. It fits, it has a good safe firmness without feeling hard, and our toddler has slept very happily on this without ever getting limbs stuck.We're having our second baby, and probably going to get a second crib and mattress, and while I think we might go with a different crib, I'm hoping to buy this same mattress again.
April 13, 2016
Keep your eye out for deals on this. Don't get it from regular department stores. I looked at Babies r us and really wanted this but didn't want to spend 160 or 180, whatever it was, on it. I got this for 84 dollars on Amazon, woohoo! Yeah, that's what it should be priced all the time. It's a great mattress, waterproof, firm yet still a little squishy, but I can see why people who spent a 120 or more might have some buyers remorse. First off, go into this purchase not expecting a lot of soybean. Expect it to be thinner than most by probably an inch. Don't be turned off by its light weight. Heavy doesn't always mean its better in this case. Despite all the enviro-friendly buyers out there making a fuss over the approximate amount of soybean, I found this mattress to be practical for sheet changes. Some reviewers were turned off by the firmness, but you really won't know what your baby is happy with until they sleep on it. Just like adults, we all like different levels of firmness. In the babies case, firmness can be a good thing cause it will make it easier for them to roll over. This mattress was an awesome buy at 84 dollars and if my munchkin decides it's too firm, the addition of a softer mattress cover can be added. No problem, cause it's worth the waterproof lining that encases this mattress. It fit perfect in my Delta 4 in 1 crib, nice and snug. Some people complained the edges were too pointy, but the fact that the edges are more like right angles actually makes the mattress fit in the crib better. No gaps.
January 14, 2014
Ok, I read over dozens of reviews of this mattress and more "organic" fiber mattresses. After all the reading and researching I picked this one because it was the best for my budget. Affordable, firm, fits the crib well and baby seems to sleep just fine on it. If I could have spent several hundred dollars on a more environmentally friendly mattress I probably would have, but it wasn't an option. The mattress only smelled like plastic when I put my nose to it when we unwrapped it. It sat in our bedroom for a week before we put the crib together and I never smelled plastic again.
July 15, 2013


  • Made with soybean oils provided by American farmers
  • Includes Airflow pockets
  • Waterproof and stain-resistant cover
  • G Like all Sealy products, this mattress is manufactured in the USA.


If you’re interested in renewable resources and highly-acclaimed brands from groups like the Women’s Choice Awards, then Sealy Soybean Foam Core Mattress is definitely the mattress for you and your little one. As far as giving you what most parents want, it covers almost all of the bases.

The company offers great return policies if you don’t like it, too. Sealy is known to work with you, no questions asked, to try and ensure that you are satisfied enough to return to them when it is time for bunk beds or even a new mattress for mom and dad.

Don’t believe us?

Ask your local mattress store and they can give you lots of stories about how easy it can be to get a return. If the jury’s still out, don’t worry, we have eight more fabulous selections to consider.

  • Soy-based foam in the mattress core is more durable than other forms of foam. It also is made from renewable resources and uses less crude oil in manufacture.
  • The light weight of this mattress makes it a snap to change bedding.
  • The waterproof, reinforced cover is pearl-embossed and very easy to wipe clean.
  • The corners are square to create a more snug fit in standard sizes and configurations of cribs
  •  The edges are sewn with lock-stitched binding. This can reduce risk of mold because it prevents leaks from seeping inside
  •  The foam is approved by CertiPUR-US due to its durability and reduced off-gassing emissions.
  • A cotton wrap surrounds the soy inner core. This offers a more decadent level of comfort
  •  A Greenguard Gold Certification means that this mattress contributes to a healthier indoor environment
  • It is backed with a lifetime warranty on all workmanship and materials.
  •  The Women’s Choice Awards voted Sealy to be America’s Best Brand for Baby during the years 2013-2016

  • A little more expensive than some other brands.
  • This mattress is most likely found in higher-end bedding stores and may be difficult to find in some discount retailers.
  • Not everyone likes the extra firmness that this mattress provides

back to menu ↑

My First Hypoallergenic Mattress with Waterproof Encasement

My First Premium Memory Foam Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress Do you love memory foam? We do too! And we love this memory foam mattress as well. The My First company designed the Memory Foam Crib Mattress with your baby in mind. It offers high-density foam that is extra firm in order to help promote a safe and restful night’s sleep.

The supportive, yet comfortable mattress helps to cushion growing bones and is firm enough to keep your baby breathing safely in any position. This company is all about safety, and if you want a mattress from a manufacturer that puts this at the forefront of every design decision, this is absolutely the company to go with.

  • Product
  • Photos

My First Premium Memory Foam Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress with Plush Removable...

Baby mattress measures 51-5/8" x 27-1/4" x 5" and fits all standard cribs; Baby crib mattress is constructed of premium CertiPUR-US certified flexible polyurethane foam; The removable crib mattress ...

Available: In stock
Buy this item
amazon amazon.com
Best baby/toddler mattress you will ever find! It feels better then my memory foam mattress and the water proof cover is so soft it's crazy!! Your child will thank you!!UPDATE**I repurchased this mattress after being so pleased with my toddlers mattress, I wanted the same one for my 7 month old. Well it's no longer the same. I'll post comparison pictures. My original mattress was purchased last year and my 2nd just came in the mail earlier today.1) new one is a 1/2 inch longer. That's a plus! Now it fits perfectly snug in the crib.2) the new mattress smells strong! Like chemicals..it's hope it airs out in the coming days. Original one had no smell at all.3) the new one is noticeably lighter in weight. I'm not too sure that's a good thing since heavier foams seem to be higher quality.4) new one has "my first mattress" stiched into the side of it, 1st one does not.5) the actual two mattresses are different colors (when you unzip the bottom) new one has maybe a half an inch of "gel memory foam" but I honestly can't tell the difference! Besides seeing that it's blue.6) new one seems to appear thinner7) lastly, the zipper and bottom material are completely redesigned. My original unzipped all the way around. New one, only unzips half way.I'm not sure how I feel about these changes.I almost feel like these changes were the comany cutting costs? I hope not. I will try and update after I get a better feel of the mattress in the following weeks. Hope this helps someone.FINAL UPDATE : 10 days later and I'm so disappointed! Still giving off a strong chemical smell! Can't close my son's door or it fills the entire room! Put my nose up to it today and gave it a wiff..minutes later feeling light headed with blurred vision..I feel horrible for letting my son take a nap on it earlier today! I'm returning this toxic mattress and biting the bullet to buy a more expensive organic mattress. BUYER BEWARE!! UNSAFE FOR YOUR PRECIOUS BABY. I don't know what happened to this company and why they changed what wasn't broken. I still love my toddlers "original" memory foam mattress because I never had an issue with off-gassing.
July 14, 2015
Alright, for those of you who REALLY don't like to read, here's all you need to know: I LOVE, LOVE, LOVE, this mattress (and so does my infant)!! Now for those of you who don't like to read too much but will do a little, I have made a Pro & Con List. And for those of you who are the real MVPs and wanna do a little more research and reading, read my full review at the end.PROS:1) Super soft, super comfortable. Seriously. The most comfortable crib mattress yet- way better than that $250 mattress I spent for my last child and at a fraction of the price.2) Comes with the nicest mattress cover. It is super soft, comfy plush, AND waterproof / mildew resistant. This is HUGE guys! Because the mattress is soft and comfortable, you don't want to have to use a thick waterproof mat underneath the baby to protect the mattress, because, well then that just takes away from the comfort.3) Fit my standard crib perfectly, and most importantly, is GREAT QUALITY AT A GREAT PRICE!!!CONS:Only 1 con: I love the mattress cover it comes with but they don't seem to sell extras separately, so if your baby does soil this one, then you'll have to use a regular crib sheet while it is in the wash (sigh).My 2 month old loved sleeping in our bed because we have a memory foam bed, and lets be honest, crib mattresses are generally by no means comfortable. They are generally very firm, and although this is safe, if baby isn't comfy, he's not sleeping through the night. Sooo, I went on a hunt for a memory foam crib mattress because it is VERY unsafe for your infant to sleep with you in your bed. I found this on Amazon, saw it had pretty good reviews (overall), and thought I'd give it a shot. To my pleasant surprise, the mattress was probably the best Amazon baby purchase I've made yet. There was no smell at all (like there are sometimes for memory foam mattresses) so my little 2 month old was sleeping on it 2 hours after unpacking it when it was bed time. As you have probably already read in my Pros & Cons list, loved how soft and comfy the mattress and mattress cover was! Also, some of the negative reviews said that the mattress was a little small for their crib, which I get, that would be a concern, but I have your standard sized crib and it first snug & perfectly. I'm so glad I quit the bassinet early and set up the crib early, because my baby wasn't sleeping well in the bassinet either, but with this mattress he sleeps just as well as if he were right beside me in our bed. #momwin!
April 10, 2017

But wait! Check out the great features that this mattress has in addition to safety:


  • The mattress measures 51-5/8″ x 27-1/4″ x 5″ and fits all standard cribs.
  • Comes with removable covers
  • 10-year warranty
  • 2 cover variants


Memory Foam Crib Mattress is a good fit if you like memory foam mattresses and want to extend the same to your baby. You get the bonus of knowing what’s inside your mattress (and not worrying about mold) because of the zip-off cover. The price is mid-range and the mattress gets great reviews for safety and ease of use.

The perfect choice for memory foam lovers. Who could ask for more?

  • Square corners prevent digging for binkies
  • The waterproof cover is removable if you need to take a fire hose to it after a blowout or a flu epidemic. You can also throw it in the washer. Removable covers make it easy to check for mold in the mattress foam beneath.
  • CeriPUR-US certified foam means baby can breathe easy
  • The mattress is hypoallergenic, so dust mites and off-gassing is not an issue. Runny noses are put on notice.
  • There is a 10-year warranty. The details can be easily found on My First’s website if you’re a lawyer or you need something to put you to sleep after a 3 AM feeding.
  • None of the icky chemicals like ozone depleters, lead, phthalates, or formaldehyde (embalming fluid in mattresses? Ew!)

  • Some chemical smell is reported when the mattress first arrives
  • The mattress must expand when it first comes. You can’t use it immediately. It only takes about 20 minutes to an hour, but you do have to wait.

back to menu ↑

Milliard Hypoallergenic Mattress with Waterproof Encasement

Milliard Hypoallergenic Baby Crib MattressIf you love memory foam but want options, keep reading! Here’s a second choice for you to consider. They tout their Milliard Hypoallergenic Matress unique, quality foam blend as being free of synthetics, durable, and comfortable. Memory foam is known to be comfortable on a baby’s growing body and free from uncomfortable springs.

One thing that is a little different about the waterproof cover on this mattress is that it covers the top and sides, but not the bottom. This has both pros and cons, as it allows the mattress to breathe and the air can help to prevent mold growth.

However, if you have ever had a major accident, liquids dripping down the side can be soaked up by the bottom.

  • Product
  • Photos

Milliard Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress or Toddler Bed Mattress With Waterproof Encasement...

The Milliard Crib Mattress uses a unique blend of foam to create the perfect combination of comfort and safety for babies and toddlers; Say goodbye to uncomfortable spring mattresses and cheap ...

Available: In stock
Buy this item
amazon amazon.com
Bought this for my kid who seemed to think his crib was a trampoline every night at bed time. Have only had it in the crib for a week, but what a difference. This does not bounce when he starts trying to jump on it, so no more night time trampoline. Also i have notice that he is going to sleep a lot faster on it. Normally he would be rolling around and changing positions for anywhere from 15 to 45 minutes when I would put him to bed. Since changing out the mattress we have had one night that he rolled around and was cranky for about 10 minutes. Even if he wasn't actually sleeping any better, the end of the crib being a bounce house at bed time is reason enough to give this 5 stars.
September 15, 2016
Shipping was quick, arrived in a small box, expanded immediately once exposed to air, and fits perfectly in the crib frame leaving absolutely no gaps in between the mattress and crib for little limbs to get caught on. Firm, and overall very pleased!
May 2, 2015
My toddler slept on this mattress for six nights. He had one accident and the picture shows the result. Note: He was wearing a diaper. As you can see he peed straight through the mattress cover that came with it.
February 14, 2017

Want to know more?


  • This mattress measures 27.5″x52″x5.5″.
  • Hypoallergenic mattress
  • Removable waterproof polka dot cover


Love memory foam?

Want to be able to allow your foam to breathe? Want a mattress that has been proven to give many kids a good night’s sleep? Check, check, and check. Milliard Hypoallergenic is a great mattress that offers a wide variety of benefits. Over 95% of reviews are positive. See for yourself if it’s for you.

The Verdict: Quality, Comfort, and ease of cleaning. Don’t you love it?

  • High-quality and unique foam blend that is free of all synthetic chemicals
  • Air can pass into the foam, reducing the chance of mold growth
  • Waterproof coating on the top and sides that is durable and easy to clean
  • Certi-PUR-US Certified free of harmful off-gassing chemicals
  • Inner fiberglass lining is fire retardant without the use of chemicals.
  • Many parents report that their kids sleep fuller and longer on this mattress

  • Open bottom part of cover can get wet if there are large wet spots.
  • The zipper is very delicate and must be handled carefully.
  • The mattress cover may discolor due to some kinds of spills.
  • There is some off gassing smell for the first days to weeks upon receiving and expanding the mattress.

back to menu ↑

Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Firmness Mattress

Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer

Want to know the most original idea for firmness in the mattress lineup? Try a double-sided Moonlight Slumber mattress with two firmness choices on either side. This allows you to use the extra-firm side that is recommended for infant safety and to then switch to the plusher side once your baby has become a toddler.

How great is that?

As a bonus, this company was founded specifically to try to make the best mattress possible. As a mission statement, there’s a pretty powerful endorsement for this mattress. It also has an antimicrobial treatment to keep your baby extra healthy.

  • Product
  • Photos

Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Firmness Crib Mattress (FFP)

The Little Dreamer mattress from Moonlight Slumber is a more economical line of mattresses, but still the safest in its class. Dual sided sleeping surface is very firm, providing for maximum comfort ...

Available: In stock
Buy this item
amazon amazon.com
As first time parents, we spent a lot of time researching every single product a parent might buy for their new baby. One of the toughest products for us to decide upon was the best mattress for our soon to be born baby boy. So many differing opinions on the necessary firmness, the best materials, foam vs spring, etc.We spent weeks struggling with this decision. After all, apart from maybe the choice of car seat, this is probably the second most important product category in terms of infant and toddler safety. I read through countless hundreds of reviews, spent time examining and measuring dozens of different mattresses in stores. But with so much conflicting information, it was still hard to make a decision.I really wanted to go with the Colgate Classica I, one of the more popular choices at the moment and one of the recommendations in the book Baby Bargains, an excellent guide for parents-to-be. However, there are lots of conflicting reviews as to whether the Classica is actually TOO firm. After testing it out in person, I happen to agree with this. The Classica is the firmest mattress I found anywhere by leaps and bounds, to the point where I felt sure that it would be uncomfortably hard.After giving up on that idea, I found this Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer to be my next choice. I liked the idea of a company founded with the sole focus of creating the best possible crib mattress. Furthermore, it has the added benefits of being made of top quality, eco-friendly materials. No worries about chemicals or low grade materials, as this product is built and designed right here in the United States out of medical grade foam. We wanted foam over spring, as foam is significantly lighter in weight, which aids in those late night sheet changes.The dual sided densities are an excellent feature. To me, the firmest side feels like the absolute perfect level of firmness for a newborn/infant. Its very firm to the point where it feels certain to be safe, but with just the slightest bit of give to feel like it will still be somewhat comfortable. The slightly less firm side is still plenty firm, but with a little extra give for when your baby gets older.I also love the fact that the mattress is side stitched. This is a feature that never would have even crossed my mind when I first started looking. Instead of the standard construction where the seems of the mattress are bonded around the top edges of the mattress, the seams on the Little Dreamer are around the middle of the sides, one long continuous seam around the entire circumference, bonded together in a way where they are almost completely flat. This means if something spills on the cover, or if the baby has an accident, there are no crevices for anything to get trapped, and no space for mold to grow. The cover is also water resistant so nothing gets soaked into the mattress.Also, for anyone looking, we are using this mattress in the Babyletto Hudson crib, and it is a perfect snug fit. The corners are very square and it perfectly fits our crib, no unsafe gaps. We love the crib too, apart from one issue with a piece that was drilled incorrectly (replaced quickly by Amazon) it is absolutely wonderful. You can read my review about it on the product page.I realize there are many cheaper options out there, but this is one product where I feel justified in spending a little extra to get something as high quality as this mattress. Buy it and never look back, you won't regret it.
January 25, 2013
I have an Moonlight Slumber dual firmness mattress I purchased from a boutique store three years ago. We absolutely love it and our toddler still uses it. We love that it is safe for infants, and it has lasted three years so far with no rips, tears, or sagging. This is one of the few splurges we believe in shelling out for. Our toddler sleeps in the same spot every night for three years and this mattress has held up wonderfully. It does not creak, make goofy noises, have air pockets, warp, sag or have a funny foam odor. It is truly a great mattress compared to others we have tested through family and friends. I would sleep on it if I could. We have used the firm side ever since we brought our baby home three years ago and he sleeps so soundly that we have never flipped it over to the less firm side.Current Purchase-- Fast Forward three years and we need two more crib mattresses. The store we purchased the first Moonlight Slumber mattress no longer carried that brand so we took to the internet to find what we needed. I was initially very discouraged after reading a particular negative review stating the mattresses being sold here were a fraud and dangerous and unsafe. After hours of research on safe crib mattresses, researching companies and the materials being used in mattresses, we were still convinced that Moonlight Slumber produces a quality mattress that met the requirements we were comfortable allowing our infants to sleep on. Now we just needed to find out where we could make our purchase.Contact with the Company--Three months later, I came back to Amazon and read the reviews again. I noticed comments under the initial negative review that initially turned us away. I added a comment asking the reviewer to please clarify which vendor sold the fraudulent mattress, to which I was never provided an answer. I also read the comments directly from a Moonlight Slumber representative, Patti Connor. I decided to look up the company directory on their website and found Patti Connor. I called her directly and spoke with her about my concerns and the negative reviews.I am so happy I continued asking questions and researching the nature of that negative review. Patti Connor was wonderful to speak with and explained the new branding of their mattresses and why some might would think it was a fraud as compared to the prior branding technique using a screen print they used a few years ago. Her comments are posted here on Amazon under the negative review if you are interested in further details. After speaking with her, she gave me one name of the online vendor that I could feel comfortable purchasing from through Amazon and I continued with my ordered using the vendor Quiverr.Our two mattresses were shipped super fast, and were exactly what I expected. We compared it to our toddler's mattress and it felt the same. The mattresses fit our DaVinci cribs perfectly with no gaps. We are very happy. We wish more companies would take the time to back up their product and comment on user reviews with facts. It is also nice to be able to call the company and speak with a real person. We also purchased a Moonlight Slumber pack and play mattress and are very happy with it as well.
April 11, 2015
My 18 month old has been sleeping on this for about 2 months and I couldn't be happier with it. The mattress seems very comfortable - not too soft or too firm and has both an infant and a toddler side. This is our 2nd crib mattress and was definitely an excellent investment. Our last mattress was a Sealy coiled mattress and lasted 3 years. This mattress is much better quality and seems more durable - I'm confident it will withstand the typical leaks and toddler bouncing. It's more affordable than many other mattresses and much better quality. It's lightweight and there was NO smell when I pulled it out of the box/packaging (many have a very chemically-smell). Like most of you, we did a lot of research and decided on this one. I'm very happy with the purchase - my daughter sleeps soundly and I expect we'll be able to keep this mattress for her toddler bed, too.
March 27, 2017


  • Measures 27.5 x 5 x 52 inches
  • Free of many toxic chemicals, including lead, phthalates, antimony, Halogens, Tris, Nanoparticles, PVC, Vinyl, PBDE, PBB, Phosphorous, Arsenic, and chlorine
  • Has Ultra-Fresh antimicrobial protection
  • Made in the USA


If you like to support small companies whose goal is to create the best product and who stand by their pieces, Moonlight Slumber mattress is a great choice. They offer a mattress that is pretty much universally considered high-quality, yet their establishment is small enough that you can talk to people easily and they will do right by you if you have problems.

Sounds pretty great, doesn’t it?

  • Certi-PUR certified foam won’t cause breathing problems for your little one due to off-gassing. It is also GREENGUARD gold certified.
  • It hinders bacteria and mold growth and doesn’t let viruses get a foothold.
  • Waterproof, permanent cover with side-stitching that can be easily wiped down with a sponge for quick cleaning.
  • Super helpful customer service staff made up of actual people who answer the phone.

  • One of the more expensive mattresses on the list
  • Some smell has been reported by a few clients for the first week or two
  • One person said that the mattress made a depression in the first year. However, customer service replaced the mattress at no charge after the warranty expired.

back to menu ↑

Simmons Kids Beautyrest Beginnings

Simmons Kids BeautyrestLike the Moonlight, this Simmons Kids Beautyrest is double-sided to allow for both toddler and infant sleep surfaces. It is a coil spring mattress, so it is a bit more bouncy than the memory foam options and a little heavier as well.

The construction consists of 231 pocket coil springs to provide consistent support whether your child sleeps in the middle or ranges all over the bed while asleep. The mattress is one of the heavier choices on the list at 26 lbs.

  • Product
  • Photos

Simmons Kids Beautyrest Beginnings Sleepy Whispers Ultra Deluxe 2 n 1 Crib...

The Beautyrest Beginnings Sleepy Whispers Ultra Deluxe 2-in-1 Crib and Toddler Mattress from Simmons Kids is made with your little one’s comfort and safety in mind. Featuring a dual-purpose design ...

Available: In stock
Buy this item
amazon amazon.com
I did research for over a week for the right mattress... The wife wasn't happy because the crib sat empty for a week, but I was happy because of my purchase.We have only had it a couple weeks. But here is why the 5 stars:Smell: No chemical smell. This was very important to me. I have a sensitive nose, and I also hate chemicals. So my nose was the first thing to touch the mattress - creepy but true.Firmness/weight/durability: very well constructed and heavy. Not cheap and very firm... I didn't notice a huge difference at all between the 2sides. If you want a memory foam mattress then go buy one, but this is not it.Material: I originally was going to buy an organic mattress but I heard they smell like pure chemicals, so after much research this is the BEST available nonorganic mattress when looking for few chemicals. I obviously chose this over an organic mattress because I listened to the reviews and I'm glad I did.Best bang for the buck right here!****UPDATE: between 4-6 weeks of use, the edge of one seam started to give way. There is now a tear 5 inches in length because of poor craftsmanship - I will be contacting the manufacturer today and will update this comment accordingly.****UPDATE: I wrote an email to customer service. I requested an RA, took very detailed images of the defective mattress, showed proof of purchase, and requested a new mattress per Simmons defect guarantee/warranty. I received a response email within 2 days with the gentleman's direct contact info (customer service contact info is on the Simmons card included with the mattress - don't bother looking online as you may get confused). I had a new mattress at my door within 5-6 days of the response email. I carefully looked over the new mattress. There are 2 air vents on each of the long sides of the mattress. 1 of the 4 vents had the material starting to come out around the vent, but I took a think object and slid it back underneath. The edging - where the original mattress came apart - is not the best! But for the price, you cant beat it - so I am leaving the 5 stars and would definitely recommend this to everyone (the edge stitching looks to be single thread - another go around with the stitch and I think this mattress is perfect).Great customer service! Turned a seemingly poor experience into a very pleasant one[sorry for the length]
March 6, 2013
I used this mattress less than one and half months, the mattress is ripping on the sides. See picture. It is also too much of a hassle to exchange it ! Very disappointed. Should have read and trust the negative reviews before I bought it.
May 7, 2015
The baby isn't here yet so I am not 100% sure about it. I bought a BeautyRest for my son when he was a baby and it had the side vents as well so when I seen this one, I figured it was the same or updated version. I was kind of taken aback when I opened it and it felt more like fabric covering it than your waterproof plastic type covering. I am a little nervous about the waterproof ability of this. Hoping it holds up in that aspect. Besides that, the mattress seems just as comfortable as my sons did. There are two sides, the firmer side meant for babies (it is recommended that they don't sleep on anything really soft) and then the reverse toddler side that is softer. It's a big mattress, which is what I remember about my sons as well. It still fit our standard sized Graco Benton crib that we bought. I haven't put sheets on it yet but I would recommend looking for toddler sheets instead of just sheets that state for the crib. While there is not much difference in size, past experience has shown that the ones that include the label "toddler" are so much easier to put on. Whatever mattress you choose, go with the most or higher coil count. This makes so much more of a difference than you could know. I had a crib that came with a mattress and my son hated it. I looked it up and it had maybe 75 coils in it. It literally folded itself in half when we stood it up outside of the mattress.
March 6, 2017

Is Memory Foam not for you? This is a great alternative!


  • Measures 52 by 27.5 by just under 6 inches
  • Coil spring mattress
  • The woven plush outer layer has a waterproof barrier
  • Double-sided construction to allow for two different firmnesses as your baby grows


Simmons Kids Beautyrest is an excellent choice if you want a mattress that will grow with your child and you’re not a fan of memory foam. Simmons is an excellent brand and their quality shows in this innovative crib mattress.

If you like traditional spring-based mattresses, you’re gonna love this!

  • No chemical smell like you will find in memory foam beds
  • Quality and firmness
  • Greenguard Gold and Certi-PUR-US certified
  • Stain-resistant waterproof cover that can be wiped down with a damp sponge to clean. This barrier is certified to be medical-grade
  • Simmons stands by their products with first-rate customer service and generous return/replacement plans

  • Heavier than other mattresses so harder to change sheets
  • Reviews show many reports of the waterproof cover separating at the seams

back to menu ↑

 Colgate Classica Firmness Eco-Friendlier Mattress

Colgate Eco Classica III Dual firmnessLet’s be clear– though the name is the same as a famous toothpaste brand, this Colgate company is a third-generation establishment that has been making mattresses since the 1950s. The Colgate Classica represents their best-selling model with a similar, 2-sided, dual firmness design as the previous two models.

It meets both Greenguard and CertiPUR standards and is encased in an Organic Cotton cover. The price on this mattress makes it on the higher middle end of the range.

  • Product
  • Photos

Colgate Eco Classica III Dual firmness Eco-Friendlier Crib mattress, Organic Cotton Cover

The Colgate EcoClassica III is from the Colgate Cradletyme Naturals collection of eco-friendlier crib mattresses, pads, and accessories. The EcoClssica III is a high quality, lightweight (9.6 lb.) , ...

Available: In stock
Buy this item
amazon amazon.com
I purchased this mattress through amazon warehouse deals.The condition was new. However, the sticker on mattress says foam is made of 92% urethane, 8% rayon. There is no mention of plant based oils, if any, used to manufacture foam like the description for the item says. The only indication the cover is organic is a cardboard sign. There is no stitching on cover that states it is organic.Very disappointing since I waited seven days to receive the item and then I have to send it back.
May 16, 2016
Bought this for our 3-year old. He was telling us his old crib mattress was "so uncomfortable." No matter what side you use (toddler or infant), this mattress is VERY FIRM. Way less comfortable than his old mattress, which is a 10-year old Sealy crib mattress with springs inside. I mean, this mattress is less comfortable than a thick rug on a hardwood floor. We will see how he sleeps on it, but I imagine we'll either be sending it back or buying some kind of pillow top pad.
October 22, 2015
I read lots of reviews before picking this mattress. I wanted GreenGuard and Certipur, plus organic cover. I read about the various foam products for foam mattresses and in my opinion, soy added mattresses are a marketing hype more than anything. The percent of soy doesn't have to be declared and there's no information or regulation regarding this. I found another kind of foam, food grade polyurethane, that sounds interested but was only able to find a couple of mattresses using it. They didn't have the other features I wanted and were crossed of the list. Our other kids mattress is innerspring coil and weighs a ton, so I wanted light weight. After evaluating many brands and models, I ended up with this one. As other reviews said, it's very firm. However, most of the reviews for mattresses that were softer mentioned sagging after a certain period of time. I'd rather start firm and not have sagging. Our boys slept on cosleeper "mattresses" which are essentially very firm cardboard, so these weren't too different for them. Based on other reviews, I was concerned about receiving a legitimate product. The cardboard insert showed a different cotton cover and the tag didn't mention anything organic. I called the company and she told me what to look for on the tag. She also said they changed the cover but didn't update the marketing insert so it would look different. She said the company is aware of this confusion on Amazon. Why they haven't corrected it, I'm not sure, but both of my mattresses for my twins are legit. All in all, I'm happy with this purchase.
November 6, 2016


  • This 6-inch thick mattress is made of multiple layers of a product that they call eco-foam.
  • Organic cotton cover
  • Made in the USA


If you want a green, organic mattress that works well, lasts throughout the toddler years, and doesn’t cost as much as a crib, then Colgate Classica is a great choice for you. Many of the reviewers of this piece chose it because they felt they were choosing the best mattress available. Check for yourself and see if you agree.

A solid, organic choice from a company devoted to green design and manufacture.

  • Soy-based urethane foam for an organic product.
  • Greenguard and CertiPUR certifications that show that it is free of over 10,000 volatile organic compounds.
  • No smell when the mattress first arrives– a rare thing for memory or closed-cell foam mattresses but a biggie for anyone sensitive to scent.
  • Super lightweight- can be lifted with one hand to change sheets, even if you are on post C-section weight restrictions.
  • The mattress can be found at major retailers like Target and Babies R Us.

  • The mattress is organic, but the labeling is confusing as it talks about being made up of rayon and urethane (both of which can be made from plant-based materials). They need to be clearer about the organic state of their pieces.
  • The cotton cover has a waterproof liner, but it is not immune to stains. You need an extra mattress pad cover.

back to menu ↑

Newton Crib Mattress Toddler Crib- Hypoallergenic

Newton Crib Mattress & Toddler MattressWe have a question for you: what’s the single biggest fear for parents when it comes to a baby going to sleep? You guessed it. Breathing issues.

Pediatricians go back and forth about the best recommendations to try to prevent breathing issues. While soft bedding is definitely one of the issues, Newton has identified another issue that we take for granted. Taka a look at the Newton Crib Mattress. The waterproof lining on most mattresses makes it so that a baby can’t breathe with their face pressed against it. So Newton has made a mattress and a cover that you can actually breathe through!

Crazy, right?

The mattress is breathable, recycled material that is not foam, but a patented material called Wovenaire that is supposed to be 90 percent air. Famous pediatricians like Dr. Sears stand behind this as a great choice– if you have the money for it.

This is definitely the priciest choice on the list so far. For those of you wondering, it’s not waterproof at all. If you want the breathability factor, you’re going to need to avoid putting a mattress pad on the mattress.

A major accident means you zip the cover off the core and throw it in the washer– the rest of the mattress can be washed in the shower or bathtub and stood vertically to dry. In a warm, dry room with air circulation, it should take less than an hour to dry.

  • Product
  • Photos

Newton Crib Mattress & Toddler Mattress: 100% Breathable, Washable, Recyclable made with...

Every inch of the Newton crib mattress was designed with your baby’s health, safety, and comfort in mind. The innovative design allows air to flow freely for optimal breathability and temperature ...

Available: In stock
Buy this item
amazon amazon.com
We bought a very expensive organic mattress for our son when he was born. It met every safety and environmental requirement there could be. Only problem was he refused to sleep on it cause it was hard as a rock! I also had a hard time leaving him in his crib overnight, worried that he would roll over and something would happen. I saw an advertisement for this mattress, did some research and decided to try it out for our newborn daughter. This mattress is amazing!! You really can put your face right on it and breath with no problem. I even have the Aden and Anais sheets on it and it barely effects the breathability. Best of all us it is actually comfortable! My daughter sleeps in her crib with no problem, and I can rest a little better knowing it's OK if she rolls over. I would definitely recommend this to any new parent, especially if you were already planning on buying one of the more expensive organic mattresses anyway.
April 22, 2016
This mattress is really light weight and gives me the piece of mind for my little one that will be here soon. A little on the pricey side but well worth it in my opinion. If you want to put the breathable sheets on it it is easy to lift out of the crib and get a nice snug fit . However I won't be using any sheets for the first 6 months just the breathable cover that it comes with. Going to try and get away with just the one cover but will see how it goes.
June 4, 2016
I really like this mattress. My baby has been sleeping on it for 2 months now! It is breathable a does not have any smell! Great product for belly sleepers
September 12, 2016


  • 100% breathable
  • Consists of 90% air and food-grade polymer to be as green as can be
  • Washable cover is designed to resist bacteria growth, keeping baby safer
  • Completely hypoallergenic


Are you all about green? Are you all about quality? Then look no further.

If mattresses were cars, Newton Crib Mattress would be the Tesla. Beautiful, sleek, high performance and innovative. Yet the greenest choice on the market at the same time. And the most expensive. If you’re looking for a place to invest some real money on your baby, why not choose the surface where they will be spending 70 percent of their first year?

  • Recommended by majorly famous pediatricians like Dr. Sears for ultimate health and safety for your little turnip.
  • A baby can get air even if their little face is squashed into the mattress surface.
  • Completely washable- extra covers can be bought and swapped out if you have a multi-mess night.
  • Made in the USA– certified Greenguard and CertiPUR, and the winner of design awards like the 2015 JPMA Innovation Award; featured as a product to watch by over a dozen major media sources including newspapers, magazines, and TV.
  • Can be used from preemie to young child, without the need to flip to the softer side.

  • A bit expensive.
  • Not waterproof and waterproof covers are discouraged. Buying this mattress means committing a lot of time to cleaning your mattress and washing covers thoroughly.

back to menu ↑

Kolcraft Cozy Soft Portable Mattress

Kolcraft Cozy Soft Portable Crib MattressOn the other end of the purchase spectrum is this Kolcraft Cozy Soft Portable Mattress. It is half the thickness as other mattresses at 2.5 inches deep, and a great choice for co-sleeper bed attachments. It is also, by far, the most affordable mattress on the list.

At 38 by 24 inches, this is too small for a normal crib. It fits mini-cribs, some hard-sided pack and plays (though it states clearly that it is not for use with soft-sided play yards), and co-sleepers very well, however.

If you’re not sure if the mattress will work in your bed, take a measurement and keep in mind that for safety, there should be less than a 2-inch gap between the mattress and the side of your sleep furniture. This hypoallergenic mattress has a durable, waterproof, wipe-down cover that is permanently stitched on. It is made in the USA, is free of toxic chemicals according to certifications, and is non-flammable without the use of chemicals.

  • Product
  • Photos

Kolcraft Cozy Soft Portable Crib Mattress, Lily

Kolcraft Cozy Soft portable crib mattress is sized at 38" x 24" x 2.5" and is a firm yet comfy mattress that fits a portable crib or mini crib. Thick hypoallergenic polyester layer is resilient, ...

Available: In stock
Buy this item
amazon amazon.com
I have a Baby Trend Nursery Center play yard. My two year old son sleeps in it often as we have had a lot of trouble getting him to sleep in his own room or bed. We wanted to transition him to consistently sleeping on his own (rather than with one foot in my back and the other punching my husband's gut) so I thought a softer mattress would be good. The mattress is perfect. It is not a coiled mattress, rather a thick piece of foam in a waterproof mattress case. The size and price are fantastic. I would say that it fits perfectly, but I suppose that if it is pressed completely against one side, there is a little over an inch gap in the width. But I would say this wouldn't matter as the mattress is going to settle in the center, it certainly isn't going to slide. I noticed a lot of people were concerned about the size being perfect, and I was as well. Great purchase!
December 29, 2016
Not too hard and not too soft, just what we expected. This mattress has a water resistant nylon cover and fits perfectly the Sorelle crib we have. One recommendation: put a receiving blanket or another pieces of non-nylon material under the bottom sheet to prevent your baby from sweating excessively. We learned this lesson during the first few nights when we noticed that little one's back and head were dripping of sweat in the morning. Other than that we already had a few accidents on the mattress and it was very easy to take off the crib and clean. No stains either..
August 31, 2016
We loved this Mattress! At first we got the dream on my 3" mattress but it was too hard! We used this mattress for the 3-in-1 dream on my Aden crib and it's a perfect fit.
October 17, 2016


  • Made in the USA
  • Reinforced, tear resistant and waterproof embossed cover
  • Perfect for smaller cribs


Need a portable mattress for the portable crib that you bring to the grandparents? This is a sturdy, cost-effective, easy-to-use choice.

Who doesn’t like that?

  • Easy on the pocketbook (because let’s face it, babies are expensive!)
  • Certified free of lead, phthalates and other toxins
  • Meets flammability testing standards without the use of chemicals
  • A great fit for mini-cribs and co-sleepers

  • Not very thick; only 2.5 inches means that it is not soft
  • Not for use with a full-sized crib. This has a very specific use only

back to menu ↑

Twilight Hypoallergenic Universal Waterproof Mattress

Davinci Twilight Hypoallergenic Universal Fit Waterproof If you want a mattress that is all-around solid in most any category, the Twilight Hypoallergenic Universal may be just the mattress for you. While this mattress doesn’t break records for innovation, it provides everything that you need without frills. It will work so well that you will pretty much take it for granted, and so will your soundly sleeping baby.

  • Product
  • Photos

Davinci Twilight Hypoallergenic Universal Fit Waterproof 6-Inch Ultra Firm Deluxe Crib Mattress

The Twilight crib mattress is crafted for simple, safe sleep. With a triple-laminated waterproof cover and six inches of flat and firm foam, the hypoallergenic Twilight is lightweight for easy ...

Available: In stock
Buy this item
amazon amazon.com
Feels great and is stiff which we wanted.I wished this product was boxed and shipped because ours came in a plastic wrap with a shipping sticker stuck on it. Some of the plastic was ripped exposing the bed. The day it was delivered it was raining and UPS decided to throw it on the grass in front of our house even though our gate was clearly open. I leave it open every day I am expecting a package along with a sign that says "All incoming packages welcome inside of gate.".I took a star away due to poor packaging from manufacturer. Has nothing to do with amazon or UPS.
March 5, 2017
I thought this mattress seemed wonderful, albeit a bit on the soft-side, for the price. However, after only 8 months of use by a small-for-her-age baby, it resembles a giant, crumpled white paper bag. Sadly, it belongs in the garbage. I spent twice as much on a similar mattress 5 years ago, and it is still being used, in excellent condition, by her toddler brother. Please don't buy this mattress. It is not only a poor value, but it is unsafe in terms of SIDS prevention.
January 18, 2016
After 2 months of sleeping on this mattress my 4 month old who is only in the 25% for weight has created an indentation in the mattress. This is not firm enough for a new born baby to safely sleep on and certainly would not hold up over time. I am currently choosing a new mattress.
December 21, 2016


  • Inexpensive
  • Waterproof and easy to clean
  • Fits any standard-sized crib
  • Hypoallergenic


Twilight Hypoallergenic Universal is a solid choice for anyone who wants a mattress that performs its job, doesn’t do anything too special, and is easy on the pocketbook. This represents a large subseet of crib shoppers. Because of this, the Twilight is a popular choice that sells well.

Is no-nonsense for you? This is a great pick, then.

  • Super light weight (four pounds! Wow!)
  • Waterproof, stitched, wipe-down cover
  • Super great price
  • Free of lead, phthalates, fire-retardants, and all of the other nasty chemicals that can pollute the air and disrupt baby’s sleep
  • No memory-foam smell (it’s not memory foam, it’s open-cell foam)

  • The foam may sag over time, not recommended for use as a hand-me-down through several kids
  • Doesn’t work with some cribs from the same DaVinci brand- some of these cribs are wider and require a different, wider mattress as a result. This can be misleading.

How We Tested

Our information is based on over 10,000 customer reviews that were collected on the different products. All of our recommended mattresses have over 1000 online reviews and are rated at more than 4 stars out of 5.

We think more is better when it comes to testing, don’t you?

Rather than rely on a single sample of a mattress to test ourselves, we learned from the huge number of mothers who have already tested and already love their mattress so much that they want to write and share their find with others.

Shopping Secrets for Saving Money on the Best Crib Mattress

The best time to get a new mattress is in the first few months of a new year. Buy last year’s model and wait for a sale. President’s day and Martin Luther King Jr. Day will both have the last of the old models (which typically only differ by color) at bargain basement prices.

Product Name Thickness Inner Structure Overall Rating Details
Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Mattress 5 in Thermo-bonded fiber 8.5 Check price
Sealy Soybean Foam Core Mattress 5 in Soy based foam 10 Check price
My First Hypoallergenic Mattress with Waterproof Encasement 5 in Polyurethane foam 9 Check price
Milliard Hypoallergenic Mattress with Waterproof Encasement 5.5 in Foam 8.5 Check price
Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Firmness Mattress 5 in Foam 8 Check price
Simmons Kids Beautyrest Beginnings 6 in Pocketed coil springs 8 Check price
Colgate Classica Firmness Eco-Friendlier Mattress 6 in Foam 9 Check price
Newton Crib Mattress Toddler Crib- Hypoallergenic 5.5 in 90% free air & 10% food-grade polymer 9.5 Check price
Kolcraft Cozy Soft Portable Mattress 2.5 in Hypoallergenic polyester 8 Check price
Twilight Hypoallergenic Universal Waterproof Mattress 6 in Foam 8 Check price

Want to know a secret way to learn about quality?

Also, if you go to a store that offers a money-back guarantee after a certain time, ask your salesperson which mattress brands are most often returned, and which ones never come back to the store. This gives you one more way to gauge satisfaction.

  • Online Shopping Secrets

If you’re saving up for a more expensive mattress, you can employ a five-step savings plan to help cover even more of the cost. If you aren’t using this trick for all of your shopping, start now! You may not be able to get all of the savings for every purchase, but you can often double- or triple-up on discounts.

  1.  Do your research and figure out which stores sell the mattress. This is important.
  2. Check on Ebates to see if any of the stores that offer the mattress give a discount if you go there through the Ebates service. This turns into cash back in your bank account.
  3. Search gift card exchange sites to buy the item with a discounted gift card. You can often get them for 10-15% off of the value of the card.
  4. Look for promo codes or sale times to maximize the cost savings.
  5. Sign up for the app associated with the store. Some will price match local competitors and give you the difference back in cash.

General Crib Mattress Care

Mattresses are pretty simple to care for. When it is dry and clean, you need to do nothing more than change sheets. If your mattress gets wet with water, it can be toweled dry. However, bodily fluids and crib mattresses are often great friends. In these cases, you can clean a mattress the same way you would wipe down a counter.

Choose a cleaner you are comfortable having near your baby’s skin (if you use bleach, you will want to wipe it down with water afterward to avoid any chemical interaction seeping through your child’s skin). Let the mattress fully dry before adding new linens. You may want to use a mattress pad cover to help keep the mattress cleaner.

However, in the case of flu, blowout diapers, or other mysterious fluids leaking from your baby, you will still want to wipe your mattress down to be on the safe side.

Сrib Mattress Pad

What’s that about a mattress pad? How do they work?

Face it: Your crib will get messy and your baby will be the cause. If you’re lucky, this will only happen to you 100 times or so throughout infancy. If you’re more normal, that number may stretch into the thousands. When this happens, your sheets will be toast. A waterproof mattress is great for keeping the fluid out of the core and preventing moldy buildup.

However, if there is a lot of fluid, it will typically run off and drip under your crib.

This is where mattress pads come in.

They are also designed to get dirty but think of mattress pads like maxi pads. They soak up and contain the mess to prevent the spread. Mattress pads come in two forms (and you can double up on both kinds), the over-the-mattress protector and the mattress top blanket.

Both offer similar protection, but one looks like a fitted sheet and is placed in a way that it won’t slip and leave you vulnerable if you have a baby who likes to perform acrobatics in his or her sleep. While the fitted mattress protectors must be regifted or tossed after you move up a mattress size, the ones that lay on top can get a whole new life if you have an older child with a bedwetting issue.

But wait! There’s more!

They also work great to lay on top of sheets during bouts of stomach flu. You can lay them in layers, and if you have a sleepy kid who throws up, you can peel one layer off and clean off your kid without making a big production of changing the sheets.

Сrib Mattress Dimensions

Crib mattresses will typically be pretty close to standard. By law, full-size crib mattresses must be at least 27-1/4 inches by 51-5/8 inches and no more than 6 inches thick. This is to fit two important safety standards.

The width and length are designed so that there is no more than a 2-inch gap between the mattress and the side of the crib. This is to keep little heads from becoming trapped in between and making it hard to breathe. The thickness rule has a similar safety background.

Thick mattresses can sink, and babies who sleep face-down may become smothered in the divot that a thick mattress provides. While neither of these things are foregone conclusions, they are all designed to use the science that is known about SIDS and try to keep your baby as safe as possible while they sleep.

Breathe easy knowing that these standards will help your baby do the same.

  • What about Co-sleepers?

So co-sleepers and mini-cribs both require a smaller mattress. These mattresses are also typically thinner, because it’s hard to get thickness and the right firmness on a smaller mattress. Be sure to buy your crib first and check the dimensions needed- if you don’t have a standard size, you’ll need to look for something that better fits your crib.

It pays to be safe with someone so precious, doesn’t it?

  • What About Organic?

Organic mattresses have three qualifiers that they must meet to be allowed to call themselves this:

Why Organic?

  • They have no synthetic materials.
  • They are not treated with chemicals (think fire-retardants, as this is the most common example).
  • They comply with organic standards (the cotton, wool, or other natural fibers were grown/raised organically).

Organic mattresses rose in popularity partially because of the fact that many chemicals that have been fast-tracked for use by the regulatory agencies were later found to be somewhat to very harmful to the people using them.

This has spawned a movement to avoid using chemicals as much as possible in the manufacture of organic items. It is terrifying to know some of the chemicals that go into the manufacture of some of the cheaper mattresses, including formaldehyde (embalming fluid!), lead, phthalates (fire-retardant chemicals) and over 10,000 other volatile chemicals that are known to be poisonous at high levels.

While we don’t know for sure if these things are harmful in the small levels that they can appear in some mattresses, things like the huge increase in asthma and allergies over the past decades is believed by some to be related to all of the chemical exposure we now get.

Don’t worry, everything on the list above has been Greenguard and CertiPUR certified– they did the work for you to make sure your little one isn’t breathing these chemicals in their sleep.

But this is for sure…

Organic mattresses are going to be free of any plastics, which means no off-gassing of those chemicals. The cotton won’t have any residual pesticides on it and it remains fireproof by using wool instead of fire-retardant chemicals.

The waterproofing on these mattresses may not be as effective, you may need to shop around. They are also a bit more expensive. But, if you are someone who wants to keep your baby’s exposure to chemicals to the absolute minimum, this is a great way to do so.

Organic mattresses are a step back to traditional mattresses from generations before. What works then can work now, but technology makes it even better.

Who doesn’t like that?

Is the Crib Mattress Hypoallergenic?

Hypoallergenic means that something does not promote allergies. When it comes to sleep, two main kinds of allergies are common: dust mites and off-gassing from fossil-fuel based foams and plastics. If you know what your issue is, you can focus there.

A hypoallergenic mattress is typically made with a latex core that is surrounded by layers of cotton (this won’t be very thick for baby because of the safety laws and requirement of firm mattresses for infants). If dust mites are the issue, wash bedding frequently and consider a dust mite cover for the mattress. This is essentially a bag that you zip around the mattress that the mites can’t get through.

Want to hear something weird?

Dust-mite pillow and mattress covers are made from the same material as typewriter ribbon. This was a lucky discovery since there aren’t a lot of people who use a manual typewriter anymore.

In Short…

Looking into the mattresses, we narrowed down the field into three niche finalists and one more general best based on overall pros. If you want a specific feature, then you will probably find your winner along with the niche choices.

  • For Luxury and Innovation, the Newton Crib Mattress

If you must have the best of the best and you will stay up every night worried about your baby’s breath, then the Newton is the hands-down winner. Choose it if your main concerns are organic, quality, and green design. Don’t choose it if price is your main concern or if you want a wipe-down waterproof mattress.

  • For Budget Mattresses, the Safety 1st.

This mattress is easy to find, easy to wash, and reported to be long-lasting by mothers who have had a series of kids sleep on these mattresses. Choose it if you want your mattress to be simple, functional, and inexpensive. Don’t choose it if you have more specific needs like an organic mattress or memory foam.

  • For Spring Mattresses, the Simmons Kids Beautyrest Beginnings

If you want something that feels more like the kind of mattress that you sleep on, this is the only mattress that made our list. Use it if you want a reputable mattress brand that offers a coil design that has been time tested. Don’t use it if you want a light mattress with a foam core.


Warranties are tricky things. If you get a mattress with a warranty, read the fine print to see what it covers?

Does your warranty cover a two-year-old with scissors and a tantrum?

Probably not. But it will cover any manufacturing defects. If your mattress says its waterproof and you find water is seeping inside, you can typically return it. Mattresses can also sink a certain amount of depth within a given time frame and qualify for a return.

Don’t understand legalese? Get help.

Your best friend in understanding the mattress differences is the sales clerk in the mattress shop. They’re the ones who have to honor the returns in a lot of cases, so they are aware who offers the “no questions asked” kind of return versus one that is only available in a few specific situations.

Bonus! If you pay with a credit card, check your credit card benefits. Sometimes you get a purchase guarantee on items. In cases like this, even if the mattress store won’t refund your money, your credit card company may do it instead.

9.5 Total Score
Our Verdict & Recommendations

And how about the the overall winner?

We, like the Women's Choice Awards, give this Accolade to the Sealy Soybean Foam Core Mattress. It offers the highest number of things that new mothers asked for. It can be wiped down to clean, and it is waterproof. The foam core is plant-based, meaning that there are few to no off-gassing issues with volatile organic compounds from fossil fuels. It can break down in a landfill.

It has all of the major green certifications. It is reasonably priced, falling squarely in the middle of the different mattress costs. It comes from Sealy, a well-known mattress company that makes quality pieces and is known to guarantee their work and offer generous return policies.

Basically, this mattress offers a safe, clean, green sleep option that is reasonably priced.

Was this your favorite, too?

The best part about lots of choices is that you can always choose from any of your favorites. Congrats on your upcoming new bundle of joy, and wishing you and your little one a safe, clean, healthy night's sleep.


We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Register New Account
Reset Password

Send this to friend